Pull-ups or Chin-ups - Which Exercise Is Better
For Upper Body?
If you are not sure whether to include pull-ups or chin-ups into
your workout, I applaud you because either one of them will do
amazing things for your upper body. Unfortunately, there is a lot
of misinformation about pull-ups versus chin-ups and which exercise
does more for you.
Suffice it to say, both the pull-up and chin-up target all your
primary back muscles about the same. The only real difference comes
into play as to how much your biceps and forearms are used.
Let me first clear up the confusion about which muscles aren't
being targeted by either a pull-up or chin-up and that's your chest
and shoulders. Those two muscle groups are primarily involved in
any type of pushing motion, whether pushing away from the body as
in performing a push-up or bench press motion. Or pushing over-head,
as you would do when performing dumbbell or barbell over-head presses.
Your chest and shoulder muscles are for pushing things away from
the body, not pulling in!
To better understand which exercise is better or more effective,
it is important to understand how muscles function. Muscles are
what move your body. The contraction of your bicep muscle is what
causes your arm to bend. When you pull your shoulders back and stick
out your chest, it is the muscles of your upper back that are contracting
to make that happen.
Muscles contract and shorten when they are being worked. They attach
at two end-points and when these two end-points move closer together, you get muscle contraction. Looking again at the bicep muscle, you
see that it attaches on the top front of your shoulder and runs
down and attaches below the crease of your elbow. When the two end-points
move closer together you get "contraction" or shortening of the bicep,
which is what makes your arm bend.
The Pulling Motion
When you look at the pull-up or chin-up, the primary muscles
involved are your latissimus dorsi, rhomboids, and trapezius muscles.
These muscles are involved in any pulling motion. Your upper back
muscles are your rhomboids and trapezius. They attach to the upper
half of your spine and run across to attach to your shoulder blades.
They are responsible for pulling your shoulders back, which causes
your chest to stick forward.
Your latissimus dorsi is the muscle that gives you that beautiful
V-shape everyone is training so hard for. It attaches to the lower
half of your spine and runs underneath and around your shoulder
and attaches to the front, top part of your shoulder.
Try This: If you place two of your fingers from your left hand
on the front of your shoulder where your latissimus attaches, which
is about where the crease of your armpit begins. Now raise your
right arm over your head as if you were getting ready to do a pull-up
What you will notice is that the end-point of your right lat muscle
is being lengthened, just as it would be when you are hanging from
a bar. Now pull your arm down as if you were doing a pull-up or chin-up.
What you will notice is that the two end-points are moving closer
together. This is because your lat muscle is starting to contract
and shorten, as if you were pulling your body up to the bar.
Repeat that motion a couple of times while keeping your left hand
touching the attachment site of your right lat muscle and you will
begin to feel and understand how muscles shorten and contract.
It is the two end-points moving closer together that tells you which
muscles are involved with that movement.
The two important things you should notice are that your chest
and shoulder muscles are not contracting and shortening, because
those muscles are not involved in any pulling motions. The second
thing you will see with this particular movement is that your hand
positioning (overhand or underhanded grip) doesn't make that much
of a difference on how those lats, rhomboids or traps are being
Your primary back muscles, lats, traps and rhomboids, are responsible
for pulling things closer to your body. That pulling motion, regardless
of an over or under-handed grip doesn't come into play that much
with regards to your back muscles. So don't let anyone tell you
that one exercise works more of your back than the other since they
are basically about the same.
The differences come with regards to the amount of stress placed
on your biceps and forearms. Both pull-ups and chin-ups will work
your bicep about the same. It's like doing bicep curls versus reverse
bicep curls (your palms are facing down, instead of up). They are
both going to hit your biceps, because it is that muscle that bends
your arm, regardless if your hands are turned one way or the other.
The real difference is that you get an additional forearm workout
when you have an over-hand grip as you would when doing a pull-up.
Why Pull-Ups Over Chin-Ups
There are two reasons why I recommend pull-ups over chin-ups.
The first is more for injury prevention. An overhand grip is more
of a natural, bio-mechanic positioning of your hands. If you notice
that when you stand and let your arms hang naturally, the palms
of your hands face back towards your body. If you were to grab a
bar overhead, the more natural position would be an overhand grip.
The under-handed grip used for chin-ups is a bit more stressful
on your wrists and elbows, especially when you add all the resistance
of your body weight to those joints.
The second reason I recommend pull-ups is simply to cut some time
out of your workout. Pull-ups target your forearm muscles much more
than chin-ups, so if you can exercise another group of muscles at
the same time you're hitting the biceps and back, then all the better.
Don't get too caught up on whether to do pull-ups or chin-ups, just
make sure you do one of those movements. If you struggle with pull-ups
or chin-ups, then try Modified Pull-Ups. It's a great way
for anyone who can't do free standing pull-ups to get the benefits
of that pulling motion.
The most important thing is to make sure you work those often neglected
back muscles. Many times, I will see people complaining of upper
back and neck pain, which is associated with people doing more push-ups
and benching movements than pulling motions. So make sure you work
those back muscles as much as you do those chest muscles. Don't
just do push-ups for your upper body, add pull-ups or "modified"
pull-ups to your routine.